Lemon Law Disputes: Arbitration vs Lawyer for Lemon Law

When it comes to car ownership, there are few experiences more harrowing and upsetting than the discovery that your newly purchased, shiny vehicle is beleaguered by persistent problems, making it a “lemon.” However, lemon laws have been put in place to protect consumers in such situations, with specific mechanisms to help you handle your defective vehicles.

Dealing with a lemon at the moment? There are two ways to solve the issue, either through arbitration or lemon law attorney representation. This is a case of arbitration vs lawyer for lemon law. If you are wondering what your best choice should be, making yourself aware of both should be your priority and this article will provide you with the clarity that you need for the two methods of legal representation. 

Lawyers working together for lemon law assist, lemonlawassist

Understanding Lemon Law Litigation

Within the context of Lemon law, litigation refers to the process of resolving disputes through the court system. When a consumer pursues litigation, they file a lawsuit against the manufacturer of their defective vehicle, and they usually seek legal remedies like compensation, vehicle replacement, or repurchase.

Process of Litigation

Before litigation, some processes may have actively taken place between both parties. They include:

1. Pre-Litigation Phase: Normally, before pursuing legal action, the consumer is required to report the defect to the manufacturer and try to settle the issue either amicably or through other means such as alternative dispute resolution which can be arbitration. If, by the end of mediation, the parties are still at odds with each other, a consumer may decide to file a lawsuit. 

2. File a complaint: If, as the consumer, you resort to suing, you will file a complaint, describe the issue briefly in the complaints, and state your desired relief. Then, the respondent, who is the manufacturer, is processed with notice and given the chance to respond to the charges.

3. Discovery: In this stage, both parties go through the disclosure phase where they present information and evidence that support their case. Some of the evidence presented may include any relevant documents, witness testimony, and expert reports among others.

4. Pre-Trial Motions: Either party may present to the court at any time and seek differing forms of relief from the court including the dismissal of certain claims or suppression of evidence.

5. Trial: If the case reaches the court of law, then both parties put forth their arguments and evidence before the judge and jury. The outcome of the lemon case is determined by the court; the court determines the outcome of the case, including the remedies and compensations that will be given to the consumer by the dealer.

6. Appeal: The end of the trial is not usually the end in some cases. After the trial, either party, whether the consumer or even the dealer, may choose to appeal the court’s decision if they have evidence that there are legal errors made during the proceedings.

Pros of Choosing Litigation

  • Comprehensive Remedies: The employment of litigation provides a wide range of remedies; too on the list are the compensation of damages, substitution of the damaged vehicle, or repurchase of the said vehicle.
  • Legal Protections: Consumers are usually provided with total legal coverage by lawsuits in courts of law in any case.
  • Precedent Setting: Cases that have ended up in favor of consumers who have had similar cases in the past help consumers with similar lemon cases to benefit from the legal precedent.
  • Access to Evidence: The Discovery phase affords you, the consumer, the opportunity to gain control over and reassess the evidence to strengthen the case.
  • Potential for Higher Compensation: Litigation can result in higher compensation than an arbitral proceeding

Cons of Choosing Litigation

  • Time-Consuming: The litigation process can be lengthy and focus on the logical or systematic and not on the emotional sides.
  • Expense: A setback for the claimant, the high costs of litigation (including legal fees, court costs, and other expenses) can make pursuing litigation a costly venture.
  • Emotional Toll: The litigation process itself is emotionally draining: stress and anxiety of the litigation, together with the uncertainty associated with the process, will inevitably affect or damage the emotional well-being of the individuals involved.
  • Public Exposure: Litigation may involve public court hearings. Hence, privacy may still be a cause of concern since the case details may be publicly scrutinized.

Exploring Lemon Law Arbitration

Arbitration is a kind of alternative dispute resolution method under which the parties agree to lay down their differences before a third party neutral who is called the arbitrator and who comprehensively passes a judgment. In the context of lemon law, arbitration is made possible as an effective way to resolve disputes that tend to be more or less formal and may get you a quicker result than that of traditional litigation. Some dealers usually provide arbitration programs to their consumers to settle disputes outside the law court.

When arbitration is being done during a lemon law case, the consumer and the manufacturer are both heard out and evidence is brought forth. Thereafter, the arbitrator who had listened to the parties announces his/her judgment. This process may include different amends which include compensation, some vehicle replacement, or repurchase. These are the ultimate resolves applicable according to the specifics of the case and the lemon law statutes. Be aware that there is a time limit for lemon law claim which can impact your decision making process

Pros of Arbitration 

  • Expedited Process: A consumer might find arbitration as the preferred approach to dispute resolution because such proceeding is often quicker than litigation, leading to an early resolution for the consumer.
  • Cost-Effective: In most cases, arbitration, as opposed to litigation, is less expensive and hence it helps consumers to save on legal fees and stat costs.
  • Informality: Arbitration often does not involve the formality of court proceedings in the sense that it manifests a more informal platform on which the parties can resolve their disputes.
  • Confidentiality: The disputes in arbitration are conducted in a confined place and it is kept away from public scrutiny.
  • Flexibility: The arbitration enables the parties to order the process regimen in the sequence that suits it and their preference, therefore creating a collaboration platform for solving disputes.

Cons of Arbitration

  • Limited Remedies: The remedies in arbitration may be compared to litigating, and as such, the consumer may feel that their grievances are not fully dealt with.
  • Uneven Playing Field: Dealers may have more knowledge and support during arbitration. As consumers may not have sufficient resources, they may end up being disadvantaged.
  • Lack of Precedent: Arbitration verdicts are not binding for other cases and do not set precedents. Consequently, their impact on future cases is limited.
  • Potential for Bias: Biases or conflicts of interest of the arbitrators might become the reasons for the non-fairness of the proceedings.

Comparison of Arbitration and Litigation

When choosing between arbitration and litigation for lemon law disputes, your choice can be dependent on several factors. Arbitration is valued for its cost-efficiency, the process is less formal and concise which normally leads to a faster resolution and savings on cost by the parties involved. Contrarily, litigation has a more systematic process including broader solutions. However, it is more expensive and more time-consuming. Consumers have to consider the complexity of their case, the desired results, and their financial status when selecting the best option for them. For instance, California’s lemon law provides protection to consumers even without warranty.

Automotive lawyers working together, lemonlawassist

In general, arbitration emphasizes speed and cost-effectiveness, thus appealing in such cases where a quick resolution is the goal and priority. Litigation, on the other hand, is known to be more formalized, perhaps generating fundamental outcomes, though at a higher risk of cost and time. Both have advantages and disadvantages and in the end, it is the one that weighs the most for the consumer in their efforts to obtain justice through lemon law that they will choose.

The Role of Lawyers in Lemon Law Cases

Lemon law cases would be impossible without lawyers as they guide consumers through an overwhelming legal maze. One of the essential points of a lemon law lawyer is their expertise. They are fluent in lemon law, hence they make correct diagnoses and come up with an effective strategy to get the most favorable outcomes for the clients.

Attorneys have a significant impact on litigation and arbitration as well. At the court, they are like the heroes of their clients, trying to find the strongest arguments, presenting the pieces of evidence, and guiding them through the legal process. As arbitrators, they draw upon their negotiation and legal background to chair the table, representing the

client and making efforts to reach a reasonable resolution. Lemon law lawyers become people’s constant allies. The chances of them helping consumers get what they deserve are high.

Let a Lemon Law Assist Lawyer Have Your Back Today

At Lemon Law Assist, we understand the complexities of lemon law cases and the frustration that comes with dealing with a defective vehicle. That’s why we’re here to offer you the support and guidance you need to navigate through this challenging time. 

When you choose Lemon Law Assist, you’re not just hiring a lawyer but you’re gaining a dedicated legal advocate who will have your back every step of the way. 

Frequently Asked Questions

When should arbitration not be used?

If your goal is to set a legal precedent or get a wider range of remedies, arbitration might not be suitable.

Why go to court instead of arbitration?

An individual might consider court as the better choice if they are looking for a more formal process, exhaustive legal remedies, or the prospect of setting legal precedent.

What are the odds of winning arbitration?

Winning odds vary, but good preparation, proper evidence, and a good legal attorney may develop the probability of success enormously.

Who typically pays for arbitration?

Both the consumer and dealer share the cost, but sometimes, this depends on the arbitration agreements or state laws.

What happens when a case goes to arbitration?

Both parties lay down their arguments and pieces of evidence before arbitrators who are reticent and thus, render a judgment that may be either binding or non-binding.

What is the biggest problem of arbitration?

The fact that the remedies are limited and there is a constant danger of biased arbitrators are the negatives of arbitration that are frequently mentioned.

Can a company force you to use arbitration?

Some companies may include “arbitration clauses” in their contracts, which require that their consumers resolve disputes through arbitration rather than litigation.

We are committed to thoroughly reviewing your case and providing expert advice regarding your legal options. Contact us now at 424-403-2820 for a free consultation

Attorney Sam Mollaei

These lawsuits claim that Nissan refused to admit the CVT transmission was defective. Instead, they tried to disguise the defects with inadequate repairs. Although some lawsuits have been settled, Nissan continues to install these faulty CVTs in newer models.

Nissan offers warranties that may cover CVT transmission problems. Knowing what is covered and how to file a claim is essential. This guide will help you navigate the warranty process and explain what to do if your claim is denied.

Get Your FREE Case Evaluation Now!

* By submitting this form, you agree to receive emails, telephone calls, and text messages regarding your inquiry. Emails, text messages, and phone calls may be automatically generated using the information you provide. Your consent to this is not necessary to obtain legal services from our firm. Msg and Data Rates may apply.


Find out if you qualify for large cash compensation