Average Lemon Law Settlement in California: A Comprehensive Guide

Buying a new car fills us with excitement about the adventures and memories we plan to create, from beach days to skiing weekends or simply enjoying a drive with family. However, this joy can quickly become frustrating when your new vehicle doesn’t perform as expected or suffers from persistent defects. In such cases, knowing your rights and seeking advice from a vehicle defect attorney can be vital.

This is especially true if you find yourself dealing with Nissan CVT, which are known issues. California’s Lemon Law, also known as The Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, is designed to protect consumers like you. If your car is considered a lemon, the law requires the manufacturer to buy back, replace, repair, or offer a cash settlement for your vehicle at no additional cost. 

However, navigating this process often requires the expertise of a skilled lemon law attorney. At Lemon Law Assist, our attorneys have a long history of successfully handling lemon law claims with a 99% success rate.

If you find yourself with a defective vehicle and need justice, don’t hesitate to call 424-403-2820 to speak with a California lemon law attorney at Lemon Law Assist.

What is Lemon Law?

Lemon Law is designed to protect consumers who end up with a defective vehicle that cannot be fixed despite multiple attempts by the manufacturer. If your car spends more time in the repair shop than on the road and the problem isn’t fixed after several tries, your car might be a “lemon.”

How Does the Lemon Law Apply in California?

In California, the Lemon Law covers new and some used cars that are still under the manufacturer’s original warranty. To qualify, your car must have a substantial defect that affects its use, value, or safety, and the manufacturer must have made a reasonable number of attempts to fix it.

What Are “Reasonable Attempts”?

The law considers it reasonable if the manufacturer tries to repair the same problem at least four times or if your car is out of service for more than 30 days due to repairs. Also, if there’s a serious safety defect, it might only need two repair attempts.

What You Can Get Under the Law

If your car is a lemon, you could get a replacement or a refund. This includes the price you paid for the car, taxes, fees, and any other costs related to the purchase. The manufacturer might deduct an amount for the use you got out of the car before the defect was discovered.

How To Know If You’re Eligible for a Lemon Law Claim

To see if you can make a Lemon Law claim in California, your car must meet certain criteria. These include:

  • The car has a serious problem that was not caused by an accident.
  • The problem is covered by the warranty.
  • You have tried to get the problem fixed a reasonable number of times, usually at least two or three, but the problem is still there.
  • The problem must be significant enough to affect the vehicle’s use, value, or safety.
  • The car has been in the shop for repairs for a certain number of days, usually more than 30 days in total.

If your situation matches the above, you might have a lemon and be eligible to make a claim under California’s Lemon Law. This law is here to ensure you’re not stuck with a defective car and to ensure the manufacturer makes it right by fixing the car, replacing it, or giving you your money back.

How to Make a Claim

To make a claim under the Lemon Law, gather all your repair records, warranty information, and any communication with the dealer or manufacturer. Then, notify the manufacturer about the problem and your intention to make a Lemon Law claim. Car manufacturers often have a process for dealing with these claims, but you should consult a lawyer if you’re not getting anywhere.

California’s Lemon Law is there to ensure that if you’re stuck with a defective car, you’re not stuck with the bill for a mistake you didn’t make. It’s about making things right when a car doesn’t meet the standards promised to you.


Average Lemon Law Settlements: What to Expect in California

When dealing with a Lemon Law claim in California, understanding what kind of settlement you might expect is crucial. Settlements in Lemon Law cases can vary widely based on several factors, but they’re designed to compensate you for the defective vehicle. 

You can receive settlements ranging from two to three times the original purchase price of your vehicle. Depending on the severity of the vehicle’s defects and their impact on its usability, safety, or value, these settlements may include a full refund, vehicle replacement, or a cash settlement.

Factors that Affect the Settlement Value of Lemon Law Claims

When you make a Lemon Law claim because your car keeps breaking down, the amount of money you might get back or the value of the replacement can vary. Here’s a look at what can change the settlement value of Lemon Law claims:

How bad is the problem?

The bigger the problem with your car, the more likely it is that you’ll get a higher settlement. If the issue makes the car unsafe to drive or in the shop more than on the road, it can seriously affect the settlement. For instance, issues like Pacifica Hybrid problems can significantly impact the value of your settlement due to the severity of the defects.

How much have you used the car?

If you were able to use the car a lot before the problems started, the manufacturer might reduce the amount they give you. They’ll consider how much value you got from the car before it turned into a lemon.

Warranty coverage

If your car’s problems are covered under warranty, you’re more likely to get a better settlement. The warranty is the manufacturer’s promise that the car will work as it should, so they’re more obligated to make it right if it doesn’t.

Repair attempts

The more times you’ve had to take your car in for the same issue without a fix, the stronger your claim is. This shows that the problem is ongoing and serious, increasing the settlement value.

Car’s downtime

If your car has spent a lot of time being repaired and you couldn’t use it, this could also increase your settlement. It’s not just about the repairs; it’s about how the car’s issues have impacted your life.

Having an experienced attorney can significantly impact the outcome of your claim. We will help you negotiate more effectively with the manufacturers and understand how to maximize the value of your claim. Contact us today for an easy and effective negotiation process.

How to Maximize Your Lemon Law Settlement in California

Getting the best possible settlement under the Lemon Law in California involves understanding your rights and knowing how to navigate the process effectively. Here are some strategies to help increase your chances of receiving a favorable settlement:

Gather comprehensive documentation

Keep detailed records of all repairs, communications with the dealership and manufacturer, and any other documents related to your vehicle’s issues. This documentation is crucial in proving your case.

Understand your rights

It is key to know the specifics of California’s Lemon Law. Understand what qualifies your vehicle as a lemon and what kind of compensation you might be eligible for.

Consult with a Lemon Law Attorney

Skilled legal representation can significantly impact the outcome of your case. Lemon law attorneys are familiar with the nuances of the law and can negotiate on your behalf to ensure you get the best possible settlement.


Often, settlements are reached through negotiation before going to court. Your attorney can use their expertise to negotiate effectively with the manufacturer, aiming for a settlement that covers your losses and compensates you fairly.

Be prepared to escalate

If initial negotiations don’t lead to a satisfactory settlement, be prepared to take further legal action. Sometimes, the prospect of going to court can motivate the manufacturer to offer a better settlement.

Employing these strategies and working with a knowledgeable attorney can maximize your chances of securing a favorable Lemon Law settlement in California.


Hiring a Lemon Law Attorney: Is It Worth It?

Dealing with a lemon vehicle is stressful, and navigating California’s Lemon Law can be complex. Hiring a Lemon Law attorney can make a significant difference in your case, reducing your stress and increasing the settlement amount you receive.

A seasoned Lemon Law attorney brings expertise and negotiation skills to your case, which can greatly influence the outcome. At Lemon Law Assist, we understand the law’s nuances and how to present your case effectively to get the best possible settlement. Legal representation can also deter manufacturers from offering low settlements, knowing that the attorney is prepared to take the case to court if necessary.

Tips for Choosing the Right Attorney

When selecting a Lemon Law attorney in California, consider the following:

  1. Experience: Look for an attorney with extensive experience in Lemon Law cases. Their track record of successful settlements or court wins is a good indicator of their capability.
  2. Specialization: Choose a lawyer who specializes in Lemon Law claims. With this, they’re more likely to be up-to-date with the latest legal developments and strategies.
  3. Reputation: Research the firm’s reputation among past clients and within the legal community. Client reviews and testimonials can provide insight into the firm’s success rate and client satisfaction.
  4. Communication: Ensure the attorney communicates clearly and keeps you informed throughout the process. You want someone who will answer your questions and explain your options.
  5. No Upfront Fees: Many reputable Lemon Law attorneys operate on a contingency basis, meaning they only get paid if you win your case. This arrangement aligns their interests with yours.

Hiring the right Lemon Law attorney can significantly affect the outcome of your claim, often leading to a better settlement than you might achieve on your own. Our firm is dedicated to helping California residents get justice for their lemon vehicles. 

With a strong track record and a focus on client satisfaction, we strive to provide the best possible outcomes for our clients. If you’re facing issues with a lemon vehicle, consider reaching out to us for a consultation. With our expertise and commitment, we aim to secure a favorable settlement for your Lemon Law claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to settle a lemon law case in California?

The time it takes to settle a Lemon Law case in California can vary widely depending on the case’s complexity, the manufacturer’s responsiveness, and whether the case is settled through negotiation or goes to trial. A Lemon Law claim can typically be resolved in 90 days or less. Cases settled out of court may be resolved quicker, while those requiring litigation can take longer due to the court’s schedule.

What is the formula for lemon law buyback in California?

The formula for a Lemon Law buyback in California includes refunding the vehicle’s purchase price, including taxes, registration fees, and any paid finance charges. From this amount, the manufacturer can deduct a usage fee based on the vehicle’s mileage at the first repair attempt for the defect. This calculation ensures consumers are compensated for the defective vehicle while accounting for the use they received before the defect was discovered.

What is the lemon law compensation in California?

Lemon Law compensation in California can include a buyback (refund) of the defective vehicle, a replacement vehicle, or a cash settlement. The specific type of compensation depends on the consumer’s preference and the negotiation outcome with the manufacturer. The buyback amount generally covers the purchase price and other costs minus a deduction for usage. In some cases, consumers may also recover costs like repair expenses, rental car fees, and attorney’s fees.

What is the time limit for the lemon law in California?

The time limit, or statute of limitations, for filing a Lemon Law claim in California is generally four years from the date the consumer first realized the vehicle had a warranty defect. It’s important to note that identifying when this clock starts can be subjective, so consulting with a Lemon Law attorney early can help ensure you don’t miss the filing deadline.

Are lemon law settlements taxable in California?

Lemon Law settlements in California are not typically considered taxable income for state or federal tax purposes. However, certain portions of the settlement, like compensation for lost wages (which is less common), may be taxable. The part of the settlement that compensates for the lawyer’s fee may also be taxable.

Do you need a lawyer for lemon law in California?

Yes. However, having a lawyer file a Lemon Law claim in California is not legally required. Having experienced legal representation can greatly benefit your case. A knowledgeable Lemon Law attorney can navigate the legal system, negotiate with manufacturers, and maximize your settlement. Given that many Lemon Law attorneys work on a contingency basis (no upfront fees, payment only if you win), many consumers opt for legal assistance to strengthen their claims.

How do you calculate buyback value?

The buyback value of a lemon vehicle in California is calculated by adding the purchase price of the vehicle (including taxes and fees) and any other costs incurred by the consumer related to the lemon (such as repair costs and towing fees). From this total, the manufacturer deducts a usage fee based on the miles driven before the first repair attempt for the defect. This ensures that the consumer is compensated for the vehicle and its related expenses minus the value of the usage they received before the defect emerged.

We are committed to thoroughly reviewing your case and providing expert advice regarding your legal options. Contact us now at 424-403-2820 for a free consultation

Attorney Sam Mollaei

These lawsuits claim that Nissan refused to admit the CVT transmission was defective. Instead, they tried to disguise the defects with inadequate repairs. Although some lawsuits have been settled, Nissan continues to install these faulty CVTs in newer models.

Nissan offers warranties that may cover CVT transmission problems. Knowing what is covered and how to file a claim is essential. This guide will help you navigate the warranty process and explain what to do if your claim is denied.

Get Your FREE Case Evaluation Now!

* By submitting this form, you agree to receive emails, telephone calls, and text messages regarding your inquiry. Emails, text messages, and phone calls may be automatically generated using the information you provide. Your consent to this is not necessary to obtain legal services from our firm. Msg and Data Rates may apply.


Find out if you qualify for large cash compensation